CCAH Members Show Up Strong at November 17th HDFC Executive Committee Meeting

Today’s Housing Finance and Development Committee (HDFC) Executive Committee meeting was another important milestone in the development of California’s new housing finance framework, as committee members worked through the second draft of the HDFC regulations. The discussion reinforced just how consequential these regulations will be for the future of affordable housing production across the state.

CCAH was proud to be well represented throughout the meeting. Public Policy Manager, Paul Shafer, provided comments adn submitted a letter on behalf of the association, and many CCAH members participated both in person and via Zoom to share their expertise and perspectives. The strong participation from our membership reflects the importance of getting these regulations right. HDFC will play a major role in how affordable housing is financed, developed, and preserved for decades to come, and it is critical that the final regulations support both affordability and long-term project success.

One of the most significant topics discussed today was the proposed tie-breaker structure and its heavy emphasis on deep income targeting. While CCAH strongly supports the need for housing serving Extremely Low-Income (ELI) and Very Low-Income (VLI) households, we remain concerned that the current approach may create unintended consequences. The proposed scoring system creates such a strong incentive for ever-deeper affordability commitments that developers may feel pressured to make promises that simply cannot be sustained over the long term. We are already seeing evidence of financial strain within portions of the affordable housing portfolio where operating revenues do not keep pace with operating expenses.

Affordable housing policy should strike a balance between serving the households with the greatest needs while ensuring properties remain financially viable for the full affordability period. CCAH believes a healthier framework would encourage a mix of affordability levels, such as approximately 30 percent ELI units, 30 percent VLI units, and 40 percent units serving households at 60 percent AMI and above. Such an approach would continue to serve the lowest-income Californians while creating stronger, more sustainable operating models for affordable housing communities.

CCAH also raised concerns about the proposed rent savings calculation within the tie-breaker. We believe the regulations should not incentivize rent levels below an average of 50 percent AMI unless long-term rental assistance is attached to those units. Deep affordability can be successful when supported by project-based vouchers or similar ongoing subsidies, but without rental assistance, deeply targeted units often create significant financial challenges for property operations. Where permanent rental assistance is available, we believe units at 30 percent AMI should appropriately receive recognition within the tie-breaker calculation.

Another major concern involves the proposed special needs incentive. As drafted, the regulations create an exceptionally large competitive advantage for projects incorporating special needs units. Special needs housing is an important and necessary housing type, and many of our members have extensive experience serving these populations. However, CCAH believes special needs housing should be one of several pathways to demonstrate public benefit, not the only pathway receiving such a significant scoring advantage. We encouraged HDFC to create other equally weighted opportunities for projects to earn public benefit credit, including developments that provide large-family housing in high-resource communities and other housing types that advance important state policy goals. The organization also recommended closer alignment with existing CDLAC standards regarding special needs incentives.

The proposed treatment of the California Housing Finance Agency (CalHFA) Mixed-Income Program (MIP) was another area where CCAH urged reconsideration. MIP was specifically designed to support mixed-income developments serving households at a broader range of income levels. The proposed HDFC tie-breaker structure effectively transforms MIP into a deeply targeted program, which is inconsistent with the program’s original purpose. CCAH recommended that MIP projects continue to use the existing CDLAC tie-breaker methodology or that HDFC modify its tie-breaker structure to preserve MIP’s intended mission.

Finally, CCAH reiterated one of the core principles reflected throughout our comments. We strongly believe HDFC should fully utilize its own bond and 4% tax credit resources before relying on other scarce and highly competitive public financing sources. Our letter recommends that HDFC fund projects directly and in full whenever possible, rather than creating pathways that compete for limited 9% tax credits. We continue to believe that HDFC’s substantial financing authority should be used to maximize housing production while preserving access to scarce resources across the broader affordable housing ecosystem.

While many questions remain unresolved, today’s discussion demonstrated the value of meaningful stakeholder engagement. We appreciate HDFC’s willingness to listen, consider alternative approaches, and continue refining the regulations. The decisions made during this process will shape affordable housing finance in California for years to come, and CCAH remains committed to ensuring the final regulations promote fairness, transparency, financial sustainability, and the production of desperately needed affordable housing.

Thank you to all of the CCAH members who took the time to participate, submit comments, attend the meeting, and lend their expertise to this effort. Your engagement continues to strengthen our industry’s collective voice and helps ensure that practical, real-world development experience is part of the conversation as HDFC moves closer to finalizing these regulations.

This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.